Name: Black Sails in the Sunset
Label: NITRO
Year: 1999
Review: THIS IS the album that perfectly captures AFI in their transition from underground punk kids to ambitious musicians. It was the first time they fully embraced their collective dark side beyond doing Misfits covers; the first time they'd really widened their scope beyond small town trappings and it's the one most frequently cited by AFI fans as The One That Changed Their Lives.
Name: The Art of Drowning
Label: NITRO
Year: 2000
Review: HAVING GOTTEN the underground on their side, here's where AFI proved they had what it took to take on the mainstream. For months you couldn't turn on MTV without seeing a heavily made-up Davey Havok whispering about how "everyone was dancing" in the 'Days Of The Phoenix'. A new level of dark meant a new level of success.
Name: December-Underground
Label: INTERSCOPE
Year: 2006
Review: OLDER AFI fans weren't sure what to do with the pompous stomp of 'Miss Murder' when it was released. Then they realised that AFI had simply become a world class rock band, who, after 16 years, were still pushing themselves. 'Decemberunderground' is full of unpredictable high gloss anthems and it is the sound of AFI exceeding all expectations. Again.
Name: Very Proud of Ya
Label: NITRO
Year: 1996
Review: THE PUNK rock album equivalent of a really thorough problem page. All those shitty teenage problems answered in 20 - count 'em - tracks. In-scene bitching? Check. Depression? Check. Desperation? Check. Pretentious assholes? Check. 'Cruise Control' even features the fabulous refrain: 'I don't wanna fuck you! So fuck you!'. Fun, fun, fun!
Name: Shut Your Mouth And Open...
Label: NITRO
Year: 1997
Review: UTTER CHAOS. Unlike the rest of AFI's back catalogue this album is not only themeless, but also somehow manages to be both totally repetitive and uncomfortably disjointed. Worst of all, the few highlights on here are covers - Filth's 'Today's Lesson' and Misfits' 'Last Caress'. The sound of AFI rushing and flailing.