At what point did you realise 5FDP could make it as monsters of modern rock?
“To this day, I’m still not sure I can fathom it. Yet in a way, I never had a doubt that I could accomplish this dream. Recording the first album, we knew we had something special, with power. We saw this huge reaction online, too. Still, the first Mayhem festival [in 2008] was the moment we really knew something was happening. We were playing 3pm on the second stage, but the festival founder told us we were outselling everyone in merch except Slipknot. He’d never seen anything like it. Merch matters. You can buy a CD to listen to a band, but if you buy the merch you’re joining the club.”
You’ve compared the dynamic between you and Ivan to the one between Star Trek’s Captain Kirk and Mr Spock, with his raw emotion contrasting your careful calculation.How important is that unique chemistry?
“The dynamic of the band is a huge part of our success. Ivan and I are polar opposites in so many ways. He’s the crazy, emotional one and I’m the logical, practical one. Yet, if you ask us both a question, we’ll come to the same answer. We’re like Yin and Yang. For a band to be successful, it’s not about making one right move, though. It’s about making 100 right moves in a row. The most important thing is the music we make.”
To what do you attribute 5FDP’s mass appeal?
“We know that we’re a very polarising band. Our fans are hardcore. They love us, and there are a lot of people who can’t stand us. But even the haters don’t compare us to other bands. We stand on our own. Beyond that, Ivan’s lyrics are always personally, politically or socially relevant. We’re not singing about history or Viking warriors. Ours is a social commentary, about the hope and the tragedy, and things we all go through in life.”
You can be pretty provocative, too…
“We like to press buttons. When everyone was on streets with signs saying ‘War is not the answer!’, we released [2009 album] War Is The Answer. When Occupy Wall Street was going on and socialism was growing in America, we brought out [2011 album] American Capitalist. That’s all intentional.”
F8 is your eighth album in 13 years. How do you keep up such a prolific output?
“We put in the work. We do 250 days on the road every year, then we start working on the next record. We don’t take vacations. We don’t stop. Don’t forget where you’ve come from, and keep connected to your fanbase.”
There’s a perception of yours as archetypically ‘American’ metal. Do you find that ironic, or fitting, for someone so clearly living the American dream?
“I’m never sure what ‘typically American music’ is. Is it about what we play? How we look? What we say? Perhaps it’s because we blew up in America first and focused mostly on touring there at the start of our career? Musically, if you look at most European metal bands, there’s classical influence in the background – it’s about harmonies and melodies and how they interact. American music is much more rooted in folk, and in rhythm and blues. It’s about the groove, the vibe and the feeling. I feel like our band is more international.”